It has taken me a few days to decide whether to write this entry. I read TJIC’s original post the day he posted it and I thought it was in very poor taste. When I got the news that his Massachusetts gun permit was suspended, I still could not defend what he said. I’ve asked myself a number of times over the last few days: do I want to associate myself with speech with which I disagree? I decided that it doesn’t matter if I agree with TJIC because ultimately I still believe:

  1. TJIC had the right to say what he said.
  2. TJIC’s constitutional rights have been violated by the Arlington Police Department and the State of Massachusetts.

For those reasons, I am TJIC.

(Image credit: Borepatch)

I’ve been trying to explain the second point on the xkcd forums for the last few days. The thrust of it is the same thing Borepatch (and everyone else) has been saying; basically, that if he hasn’t even been charged with a crime then due process for denying an individual his constitutionally protected rights has not been served. As I wrote there:

Would you be cool with it if all the government had to do to limit your freedom of speech was suspend a license? A license they don’t even have to grant you in the first place, the issuance of which is entirely up to the policies of your local chief of police or sheriff? Maybe it’ll be a graduated license. It’ll be easy to get one if all you want to do is talk about sports, but if you want to talk about politics or religion you need to get a Class A License to Offend, for which you need to show cause and take an anger management class. And even then you can’t use hate speech or any words that aren’t on the Massachusetts Approved Diction Roster. You can get one without trouble in the suburbs, but in Boston you had better be a professional journalist or, well, I guess you won’t be talking about politics because the Chief of Police there is a hardass who thinks only the Right People need the freedom of speech. If you get caught spouting off about the Governor without a license that’s a felony. Does that sound like an individual right with constitutional protection to you?

I fail to see how TJIC’s First, Second, and Fourth Amendment rights were not violated by confiscating his property without due process. I hope that something good can come of this, namely that we can get a judgment against the Arlington PD and the State of Massachusetts stating in no uncertain terms that their restrictions on constitutionally guaranteed rights are Not Okay. Perhaps a measure of freedom will be restored to its birthplace. I am cautiously optimistic, but I think it is more likely that the governmental bodies involved will try to sweep this incident under the rug as it enters the judicial system and settle the case without conceding anything.

5 Responses to “I Am TJIC”

  1. Linoge Says:

    How quickly some people are willing to give up other people’s rights at the drop of a whim… I wonder if they would be as enthusiastic if it were their Constitutinally-protected rights being arbitrarily and whimsically infringed.

  2. Eric Says:

    I agree, I wonder if people would be upset if free-speech, or the right to gather was the right being trampled on if it would make a differnece

  3. Ben J. Matthews Says:

    Totally agree. Free Speech has gotten trampled enough.

    “Happy To Survive Magazine had a good article on this same thing this month in Itunes.


    So it looks like you are ahead of everybody.

  4. 1389AD Says:

    The only “permit” we need is the Second Amendment, which ratifies a right that we already have.

    Have you seen this?

    3D Print your own high capacity magazines and other firearms parts


  5. http://4ri.org/capsychicsho Says:

    How about you, have you at any time thought about exploring your psychic aspect?
    Sometimes, you would have the feedback when you get the psychic assist.

    People will be making audio dependable choices.

    My web page – online psychic reading, http://4ri.org/capsychicsho,

Leave a Reply